VOTING - Bomb Site Detailing Contest

[AngryAngus]

Voting - CSGOMaps Bomb Site Detailing Contest

Oi! What the bloody 'eck is this?

The CSGOMaps Bombsite detailing contest has officially ended.
It is now time to vote for the best looking map!


Voting


The votes will be based off purely aesthetical appeal, or in layman's terms how sexy the map looks to the eye.
So I STRONGLY recommend that you download the maps and check them out in game, because screenshots only tell half the story.

To vote you should reply to this thread in the following format, ranking the maps.

1. Vote for best map
2. Vote for second best map
3. Vote for third best map

I'd like to thank the entries and wish them the best of luck!



Entries


Bombsite - Evicted
Bombsite - Kinanischka
Bombsite - joppie

[kinanischka]

Are we eligible for voting?

[AngryAngus]

(10-24-2012 07:13 PM)kinanischka Wrote:  Are we eligible for voting?

Those that entered are not allowed to vote sorry, this only applies to this contest however due to the low number of entries.

[yyler]

This is hard because they are all pretty good from the screenshots. I will download them and edit votes into this post later.

Edit:

Kinanischka
Evicted
j0ppie

[AngryAngus]

My vote...

1. Kinanischka
2. j0ppie
3. Evicted

[Tanuki]

After looking through the maps in game here are my picks. I included some reasoning:

1. j0ppie
Pros:
-Good command of space including inaccessible spaces
-Well done lighting and scene composition (at every angle the scene looks good)
Cons:
-The wrong texture is used on the walls
-no sound (I consider this a detail)

2. Kinanischka
Pros:
-Helicopter is really really neat.
-Good placement of industrial details
Cons:
-Too much rain negatively distorts the scene.
-Building architecture is largely formless
-Strange mix of multi-language signage
3. Evicted
Pros:
-soundscape fits the scene very well
Cons:
-Rough geometric construction
-Volumetric lights are rather bright and do not match the scene lighting

[death180]

1. Evicted
2. j0ppie
3. Kinanischka

[VEC_Avo]

Very difficult to judge, they are all three beautiful, but when we have to...

1. Evicted
Pros :
Ambiance, environment, sounds, lights game...
Nice props choice and placement
Detailed inaccessible room
Would love to play on this kind of architecture *
Cons :
A missing texture on loudspeakers (and models errors in console)
Several level design problems for players movement *

2. Kinanischka
Pros :
Ambiance, police cars, sounds, helico...
Battered road
Helico
Cons :
Too much rain/mist, even inside van and garbage
Several missing textures on sidewalk, porch and windows, and had to build cubemaps myself
Too wide empty space, bombsite too open *

3. joppie
Pros :
Nice use of this theme
Great inaccessible paths upstairs
Corpse behind garbages
Cons :
Classical in every way
Missing an ambiance, a nature, an identity, to attract the eye
Too wide access paths *

Out of competition. drspud
Pros :
Waouuuuh
What an ambiance, I'd think I was in Avoriaz
Would love to play on this kind of map
Cons :
Out of competition
When do you plan this complete map ?

* Not taked into account for aesthetic jugging

[AngryAngus]

Voting will end two days from now.

[AngryAngus]

The votes are in.

http://forums.csgomaps.net/showthread.php?tid=175